Chapter 8: That’s Life

There are only two certainties in this world: birth and death. Every single living person was born from their mother and will one day die. This chapter explores the evolution of both of these natural processes. Ironically, Dr. Moalem begins this chapter with the topic of aging. Through studying the rare disease, progeria, which causes extreme accelerated aging that results in death by the age of 30, scientists discovered that the cells of people with progeria look almost identical to normal elderly people. This is significant because it indicates that the aging process is programmed into cells, not just a result of the wear and tear of living. Through further exploration, it was discovered that cells are preprogrammed to only be able to divide a certain number of times. This concept has led scientists to hypothesize why the body would, in a way, self sabotage. So far there are two generally accepted hypotheses for why the body ages and ultimately is programmed to die. First is the concept that aging and death of humans makes room for new humans to be born, accelerating the rate of evolution. Another hypothesis is that death is the elimination of individuals who have likely acquired parasites throughout their lives in order to prevent infecting younger generations.

 

Now that we have the demoralizing “you will get old and die” section out of the way, let’s move on to a brighter topic in evolutionary science: birth. Dr. Moalem discusses how childbirth in humans generally lasts longer and is riskier than that of other primates. This has been previously attributed to the obstetrical dilemma, or the hypothesis that selection for both bipedalism, which is accompanied by a narrowing of the pelvis, and big brains in humans resulted in a more difficult birthing process. This leads to the question of what drove evolution towards these traits that do not seem to work together? One hypothesis for bipedalism is the savanna hypothesis which states that our ancestors moved from forests to grasslands, probably due to environmental change, where there was a harder way of life. Males had to hunt for game with tools and needed to be bipedal to travel long distances quickly and scan for prey. One major problem with this hypothesis is that it only focuses on males and does not explain at all why women and children also would have evolved. Another hypothesis is the aquatic ape theory which says that our ancestors spent time both on land and in and around water, leading to the evolution of traits that benefit aquatic environments such as less hair and more fat. In this hypothesis, bipedalism evolved in order to wade deeper while still being able to breath. Dr. Moalem shows a strong preference for this hypothesis and then proceeds to make a case for water birth over contemporary birthing measures. Dr. Moalem sites studies saying that women who give birth in water experienced an easier and accelerated delivery process, probably because babies are preprogrammed for being born into an aquatic environment.

Chapter 7: Methyl Madness

One of the newest disciplines in both the field of genetics and science in general is epigenetics. This is a modern discipline that studies how environmental exposure can influence the expression or suppression of specific genes without altering the DNA of the individual. Essentially, through the understanding of epigenetics, two people with the exact same DNA, such as identical twins, can manifest their genes differently based on differing experiences and environment. DNA Methylation, or the binding of a methyl group to a specific gene, acts as a switch, effectively suppressing the target gene without removing it from the genome. Another form of epigenetics is the effective removal of methyl groups from genes in order to express them. Both of these scenarios can be beneficial depending on what gene is being targeted. These acquired traits are then able to be inherited by offspring. Most of the initial studies that led to the concept of epigenetics focused on maternal effect, or the methylation within a fetus being determined by the decisions and environment of it’s mother. Maternal effect has more recently been linked to the ever increasing rate of childhood obesity. The thrifty phenotype hypothesis predicts that when a pregnant mother eats a diet rich in fats but lacking in nutritional value (such as a diet of primarily fast food), their fetus thinks it is being born into an environment lacking nutrients. Consequently, the fetus undergoes methylation that results in a “thrifty” metabolism which is better equipped at storing energy. If this were to occur during a time of actual famine, the fetus would be better able to survive. In the modern world, where food is readily available, when a baby is born with a “thrifty” metabolism it results in obesity. This is just one example of epigenetics at work. Make no mistake, gene suppression and expressions via methylation is occurring frequently in individuals throughout their life times. This is still such a new concept and area of study. Much more research must be done on the matter in order to truly understand how our environment and items we ingest are affecting us. Dr. Moalem suggests that this will be a promising area for treatment options in the future of medicine.

Chapter 6: Jump Into the Gene Pool

Historically, a person’s DNA has been thought of as a rigid template for growth, with a single gene coding for a specific trait. In this model, the only way that evolution could occur is through natural selection acting on random mutations to the genome. It has since been proved that the process is a bit more complicated than this. It seems as if only 3% of a person’s DNA actually codes for specific proteins and the remaining 97% is noncoding DNA, meaning we are not quite positive of its purpose. In addition, the one gene per trait theory has been replaced by the thought that genes are integrative and multiple genes can contribute to a singular trait and vice versa. It has also been determined that random mutation would not be able to explain certain traits that have evolved because the chance that the correct mutation occurred in the exact correct location is almost unfathomable. Instead, much research has been conducted that has discovered the existence of “jumping genes.” Jumping genes, also called transposons, are activated during times of internal or external stress, either copying and pasting or cutting and pasting themselves into specific segments of coding DNA. It is currently understood that by doing this, jumping genes are increasing the rate of mutation in an organized fashion and increasing the likelihood that they will, in a way, “speed up” the evolutionary process in order to better survive in their current situation. About 50% of noncoding DNA is now considered to consist of numerous jumping genes. Even more recently, researchers have come across new evidence that points to viruses as being the main cause of this noncoding portion of our DNA. In the chapter, Dr. Moalem indicates that jumping genes, and therefore noncoding DNA, have a composition that looks very similar to that of viruses. Since the beginning of history, viruses have been infecting host cells and taking over the cells genetic machinery in order to replicate. Some viruses, known as retroviruses, are even able to write themselves into their host’s DNA, literally changing a person’s genetic makeup. The current theory is that over time, some virus DNA that has been inserted into the human genome has been beneficial, such as jumping genes, and has increased the rate and ability of human evolution.

Chapter 5: Of Microbes and Men

Every organism on earth has the same end goals: to survive and reproduce. In the case of parasites and pathogens, this is no different. Generally, the term “parasite” comes with a negative connotation and causes people to immediately think of severe illnesses, such as malaria. In reality, parasites and pathogens do not always have such severe effects on their hosts. They are simply manipulating their host in the method that will result in the greatest likelihood of their survival and proliferation. While malaria is a terrible diseases, the reason it basically incapacitates its host is to make it easy for other mosquitoes to bite the infected host and pass the parasite on to other unsuspecting individuals. This extreme level of virulence is not necessarily the norm. Some microbes, such as the common cold,  actually want their host to be well enough to go about with their daily activities because it provides more opportunities for the virus to be passed to other individuals. This chapter introduces the theory that if we use our understanding that pathogens evolve in order to best increase their probability of transmission, and we work to shut down all modes of transmission and transportation other than direct human to human interaction, we could actually push the evolution of pathogens to less virulent strains. While this may seem like a long shot and certainly will not work with all harmful microbes, it is worth a try. It is about time we manipulated pathogens instead of them manipulating us.

Chapter 4: Hey Bud, Can You Do Me A Fava?

There is much folklore surrounding the infamous fava beans. The most famous is that Pythagora, the ancient scholar, warned all of his students to avoid them at all costs. The million dollar question that people have been trying to figure out ever since is why? Did Pythagoras actually say this, and if so, was it a metaphor or to be taken literally? In this chapter Dr. Moalem argues that Pythagoras’s warning was probably meant to be taken literally. Favism is the most common enzyme deficiency in the world today and is also a heritable disease. If people who have favism, and thus lack the G6PD enzyme, eat fava beans it can result in death due to sudden anemia. The G6PD enzyme is thought to be responsible for maintaining the integrity of the cell, specifically in red blood cells. Free radicals on the other hand have unpaired electrons that are looking to pair with already pair molecules, thus threatening the stability of the cell. Therefore, one major role of the G6PD enzyme is removing free radicals. The reason people with favism have an adverse reaction to fava beans is because the beans contain compounds that produce free radicals which leads to the lysing of red blood cells when the G6PD enzyme is not present. One notable observation is that the places where favism is most common coincidentally overlaps with the places where fava beans are harvested and eaten. So, what is the evolutionary advantage of this seemingly detrimental disease? Dr. Moalem believes that lacking the G6PD enzyme results in red blood cells that are less hospitable to malaria. This would mean that favism is selected for because it provides resistance to malaria, which explains why it is predominantly found in tropical climates where mosquitoes are common. You may be wondering why these same populations would then produce and eat the majority of the world’s fava beans? Dr Moalem has an explanation for this as well. He says that eating fava beans, which increases free radicals, also makes regular red blood cells less hospitable to malaria, acting as a natural preventative care measure.

Chapter 3: Cholesterol Also Rises

While cholesterol is often regarded in a negative connotation, it actually is necessary for survival. Cholesterol is responsible for making and maintaining the cell membrane, it is an essential component of some hormone molecules, and is necessary for the production of vitamin D. In order for the body to produce vitamin D, UVB light must hit the skin and stimulate the conversion of cholesterol into vitamin D. Interestingly, UVB light also destroys folate in the skin, which is necessary for DNA replication. It is well known that humans around the globe have various skin colors, which has widely been accepted as a result of differing levels of melanin production. Individuals with darker skin evolved in climates that received a lot of strong sunlight which prompted the increased production of melanin in order to prevent the absorption of too much UVB light and protect against excessive folate degradation. Subsequently, the apolipoprotein E (ApoE4) gene is prevalent in populations with dark skin and has been linked to an increase in cholesterol. From the perspective of Dr. Moalem, this makes complete sense. Since less UVB light is able to penetrate the dark skin of these populations, the ApoE4 gene was selected for in order to increase the amount of circulating cholesterol to increase Vitamin D production. The only other population that the ApoE4 gene is largely seen in is lighter-skinned people of Northern Europe. This can be explained through a similar process. Since the Northern Europeans experience very little sunlight, even though they have light skin it is still difficult for them to produce enough vitamin D. With the ApoE4 gene they have more circulating cholesterol and therefore an increased chance of vitamin D production. This would help explain the high rate of heart disease, especially among African Americans.

Chapter 2: A Spoonful of Sugar Makes the Temperature Go Down

Insulin dependent diabetes is one of the most common chronic diseases in the world today. This is a hereditary disease that is caused by the inability of Beta cells in the pancreas to produce insulin. This is problematic because insulin is responsible for breaking down glucose present in the blood for energy and therefore keeps blood glucose levels from getting too high. While diabetes is considered a heritable disease, it is believed that genetics give you a predisposition for developing diabetes and then it is some environmental cue that actually prompts the onset. When trying to determine what evolutionary advantage could come from having diabetes, Dr. Moalem noticed there are some populations in which the incidence rate is very high and other populations where diabetes is virtually nonexistent. Insulin dependent diabetes is most common at high latitudes, predominantly in Finland, Sweden, the UK, and Norway, whereas in populations at low latitudes, like the people of African and Hispanic descent, diabetes is quite rare. Upon much research, Dr. Moalem came to the conclusion that insulin dependent diabetes must promote survival in extremely cold temperatures. While this is a hotly debated hypothesis, there are many facts to back it up. Diabetes is characterized by excessive water loss and excessive increase in blood glucose levels. This may be beneficial in very cold climates because the decrease in water volumes means there is less water in the body that could potentially freeze and the large amount of sugar in the blood significantly lowers its freezing point. It is believed that whatever gene is responsible for diabetes was selected for during the Younger Dryas, the most recent Ice Age. In support of this theory, children are most often diagnosed with diabetes in the colder months when the temperature begins to drop.

Chapter 1: Ironing It Out

This chapter primarily focuses on hemochromatosis, a hereditary disease that results in the disruption of the negative feedback loop used to tell the body to stop absorbing iron. This results in an extreme excess of iron within the body. The increased iron levels cause pain and damage to joints, internal organs, and chemical properties of the body. If left alone, hemochromatosis can ultimately lead to death. The only way to treat this disease is to literally drain blood from the body to decrease iron levels. The gene that causes hemochromatosis is most common in people of Western European descent. Why has this gene not been selected against throughout the years? Dr. Sharon Moalem makes a strong argument towards the notion that this gene is responsible for an increased immunity to the bubonic plague, which predominantly affected Western Europe in the fourteenth century. Dr. Moalem indicates that all life forms need iron to live and proliferate and that many illnesses are able to overtake the immune system by absorbing the iron present in the macrophages sent to kill them. What makes people with hemochromatosis unique, is that interestingly, their macrophages have been found to lack the presence of iron, making them ideal for combating illness. So, it is believed that hemochromatosis originally came about via a genetic mutation that occurred before the bubonic plague and then was selected for during the bubonic plague, leading to the prevalence of the gene that causes hemochromatosis in the population today.