The Importance of Image in Debates
Posted on October 4, 2012 in Debate Significance by Malcolm
Debates matter. I would argue that it is not the material debated so much as how the candidates appear while debating. Since the advent of television and debates during Kennedy/Nixon, these events have become moments of likeability and image. Those who watch the debates are focused on how comfortable or how commanding each candidate looks up on stage. What they are saying is important but it is the same talking points and facts that the public hears during the entire campaign. This is a moment of live national exposure for each candidate. Reactions on twitter for last night’s debate were overwhelmingly aimed towards how Romney or Obama were being perceived. I believe that the debates are essentially a performance, acing your lines and handling yourself in a way that can benefit your image as a knowledgable, confident leader. This is something the public reacts strongly to. The debates may not reveal anything important or novel within each candidate’s policy, ideology, or plans but it still remains an important force on the road to the White House. Candidates can really define themselves during these moments and at other times, they can see their unraveling. Should these debates matter for more intellectual reasons? Probably but in this visual media that focuses on the horse race and campaign strategy, image reigns. And the debates set a perfect stage for the public to see how each candidate conducts himself in a national event. It is not about what they are saying. It’s about how they are saying it.
I totally agree with Malcolm’s analysis of the significance of the debate. While new media sources may render the actual facts and platforms share by the candidates irrelevant, as they are mostly “old news,” the debate remains significant. It is in the debates, like Malcolm says, that we can get an image of our next President, whoever it may be, in a direct address to the voters. Does the average viewer know the truth of the statements made by either candidate? Likely not. However, they surely will remember how the lines were delivered. Great post, Malcolm!