Why did Obama anger Catholics? A straightforward response to this question has been provided by E.J. Dionne—the Obama administration’s failure to acknowledge Catholic universities’ and Catholic hospitals’ unique circumstances and exempt them from requirements related to contraceptive coverage was viewed as a betrayal.
In this post, however, I want to present this question as a puzzle. In hindsight, as with most historical events, it may seem obvious that the issue would blow up the way it did. After all, it IS what actually happened. But I want to problematize that view by exploring why Obama MIGHT have thought that Catholics in general and, at the very least, liberal Catholics would have let this particular issue slide.
Continue reading