L. Song, A. Striegel, “Leveraging Frame Aggregation to Improve Access Point Selection,” in Proc. of Mobiworld 17, workshop at IEEE INFOCOM, Atlanta, GA, May 2017.
======= Mobiworld Review 1 =======
*** Detailed Comments: Please provide detailed comments that will help the TPC assess the paper and help provide feedback to the authors.
1. The paper is well organized. Its concept flow is clear and smooth.
2. How to choose an SP for a mobile device is quite a problem? Often we choose the one with the highest radio signals. This paper analyzes the other possible metrics and claims that 86 % of improvement has been achieved.
3. The experiments are well done and discussions are clear.
4. The abstract and conclusion are sufficient and clear.
*** Familiarity: Rate your familiarity with the topic of the paper.
Expert (I conduct(ed) active research work in this topic) (4)
*** Overall Recommendation: Your overall rating (Please try giving as few borderlines as possible).
weak accept (4)
======= Mobiworld Review 2 =======
*** Detailed Comments: Please provide detailed comments that will help the TPC assess the paper and help provide feedback to the authors.
This paper’s main contribution is reasonable in my opinion.
However, one thing which I would like to point out is that there is no comparison analysis.
*** Familiarity: Rate your familiarity with the topic of the paper.
Familiar (I am well aware of research work in this topic) (3)
*** Overall Recommendation: Your overall rating (Please try giving as few borderlines as possible).
weak accept (4)