Language Learning in the Age of LLMs; or, On Getting Scooped by Germans

After a long run of somewhat pedantic articles on my favorite sub-sub-specialty, I thought I’d take an opportunity to indulge myself a bit with a different topic. I’d like to make a case for why, in an age of near-instant and reasonably accurate translations provided by the likes of ChatGPT and Grok, it still behooves the student of the Middle Ages to learn languages, including modern ones [1].

But first, a personal detour. I have a vivid memory of sitting in the Medieval Institute, roughly 12 years ago, and making a Discovery. The subject of my dissertation, Humbert of Silva Candida, had not directly quoted Epiphanius of Salamis, as implied by his text, but rather a redaction of the De haeresibus of St. Augustine now known as the Liber Praedestinatus (possibly the work of Arnobius the Younger). This attribution had escaped Cornelius Will, the most recent person to have published an edition of Humbert’s works on the conflict between Rome and Constantinople, and I was exceedingly pleased with myself. I just as clearly remember, a few months later, sitting in the same room and discovering an article written by Anton Michel, a well-known scholar in my field who was active in the first half of the 20th century, in which he made exactly the same identification a century, to the year, before I had [2].

Over the course of the same project, I made a second, and even better, discovery. One of Humbert’s works quotes a passage in Greek and attributes it to St. John Damascene. The text is hopelessly garbled in the published edition, but a few of the manuscripts preserve the Greek a little bit better and some even have an interlinear gloss translating it into mostly comprehensible Latin. After an inordinate amount of time digging around, I was finally able to identify the source – one of the variable texts used in the Orthros (Matins) service of the Byzantine rite. This was, in the words of one of my dissertation committee members, a “real discovery”, and I was sufficiently impressed with my own sleuthing that I incorporated this work into an article a couple years later. Of course, the nature of the academic world is that mistakes you don’t catch yourself are often caught for you, and the corrections are printed, public, and permanent. In my case, a scholar at the University of Bologna pointed out that the same identification had already been made by Georg Hofmann way back in 1950 [3].

An example of the formidable Fraktur (Breitkopf). Note also the visual contrast of an Antiqua typeface for the Latin. Public domain.

Upon some reflection, I think that the common theme in both of these misses—one caught in time, the other not—was a failure to grapple sufficiently with secondary literature written in German, which includes the work of both of the scholars mentioned above. This failure, in turn, was brought about by my tendency to avoid German sources, stemming from my less than fully confident reading abilities in that language. Seeing a book written in Fraktur still sends me into conniptions. I was uncomfortable with the language, and so I avoided anything that did not have an obvious bearing on my own research. But, as it happens, it is not possible to ignore German scholarship, not even a little bit, without being embarrassed. Hence, my plea to current and prospective students in the field: do as I say, not as I have done.

Learn your languages properly. And this is where the formal requirements of a graduate program (for example, those of Notre Dame’s Medieval Institute) are necessary but insufficient. Typically, proving reading language proficiency for academic purposes requires being able to complete a close translation of a prose selection in the target language—a page from an article in French, for example—with the help of a dictionary. This is precisely the level of language ability required to be able to quote a passage from foreign-language scholarship or to double-check a translation rendered by a large language model (for the less pure-minded), which are indeed absolutely necessary skills. They are, however, a far cry from a comfortable working knowledge of the language in question. Instead, I’d propose what I’d call a “library stacks test” as the first part of an informal guide: can someone pull a book in the target language that’s related to their field of study off a shelf, spend a minute flipping through it, and have a reasonably good idea of the contents and how it relates to his or her work? This then would be followed by a reading test – is it possible to read the book (or, as we used to say while preparing for our comprehensive exams “to familiarize oneself with a book”) and be able to incorporate it into a paper in a reasonable amount of time, that is, in not too much longer than it would take for a book of similar length written in English?

These are both tests in which, fortunately or not, the abilities of large language models (for those inclined to use them) fail to deliver much assistance. Microsoft CoPilot, even when not suffering from a global outage, is unable to give an opinion in the moment on the utility of something written in Italian that you happen to discover right next to the book you were originally looking for on the shelf. To rely on LLMs, then, is to abandon the potential for so many serendipitous discoveries made in the library stacks. And even if we allow that an LLM can deliver an adequate translation of a book, there remains a mountain of secondary literature in the field that remains undigitized and thereby untouchable without a serious effort to digitize and organize it. In practice, I would suggest that this is a significant enough barrier to prevent ease of access, which is the core of the problem.

So what would I recommend to a prospective student (bearing in mind that I didn’t do this myself)? The Medieval Institute at Notre Dame requires one medieval research language (typically Latin) and two modern research languages (often French and German). Latin (or Greek, Arabic, Hebrew, etc.) is a topic unto itself and deserves separate consideration. For the modern languages, though, French and German do probably cover a fair bit of the secondary literature for most of the disciplines represented in an interdisciplinary program for medievalists. So far, so good. As I suggested before, though, it is the level of familiarity and comfort that is at issue. For that, I’ll go out on a limb and suggest that a B2 level, or upper-intermediate, using the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages, is probably about what we ought to aim for. I’ll go out on another limb entirely to suggest that this include spoken proficiency, as well as reading. There are very many superb scholars who don’t speak a lick of anything other than English, but it’s comfort we’re going for here, and I think that spending a couple hundred hours chatting with tutors, friends, or strangers in the target language is the most efficient way to get there. By way of anecdotal evidence, I know of several other students, wiser than I, who took the opportunity to acquire a spoken command of their research languages. I’d be willing to bet any amount of money that none of them regretted it [4].

While this appears, admittedly, a formidable hurdle for many American students, reared, as I was, as monoglots, it is by no means insurmountable. The Foreign Service Institute, run by the US Department of State, suggests that it takes a native English speaker about 600 hours to learn French and 900 hours to learn German to a level of professional proficiency. I can’t speak for German, but my experience with other Romance languages outside of my academic study suggests that it might take a little less time than that, especially for a motivated student focusing deliberately (and with a background in) specialized academic vocabulary. But all that is to say, it’s a manageable goal, particularly for the student who has the good fortune to start in college or high school (or earlier). It’s also never been easier. We live in an age of true abundance when it comes to language learning materials: a plethora of apps (admittedly, of widely varying quality), online tutors, and a legion of YouTubers making “comprehensible input” style videos. Formal classroom instruction and immersion trips can be nice, but they are by no means necessary [5].

I’m late to the game myself but now, a decade overdue, trying to make up for lost time. I can only recommend that you, O reader, start sooner.

Nick Kamas
PhD in Medieval Studies
University of Notre Dame

1. I should be clear about my target audience: I mean to address very junior or aspiring anglophone scholars. I wouldn’t dare presume to lecture anyone else.

2. Anton Michel, “Praedestinatus, eien ungenannte Quelle Kardinal Humberts im Kampfe gegen Kerullarios (1053/1054)”, in Festgabe Alois Knöpfler zur Vollendung des 70. Lebensjahres (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herdersche Verlagshandlung, 1917), 240–247.

3. Along with noting a rather embarrassing transcription error that I had made. Luigi D’Amelia, “‘Translating Bread:’ Notions of Etymology and Theory of Meaning in the Latin-Greek Controversy on the Azymes”, in Latin Translations of Greek Texts from the 11th to the 13th Century (Leiden: Brill, 2025), 302.

4. I write this line with my old friend, neighbor, and early mentor Steve Molvarec in mind. May his memory be eternal.

5. And may or may not even be all that helpful, depending on the instruction methods employed. For this and the notion of “comprehensible input”, see the work of Stephen Krashen, mostly available here.

Medieval Animal Psychology and the Mirror Self-Recognition Test

If you put a puppy or a kitten in front of a mirror for the first time, how would it react? Social media is full of videos of dogs sniffing or barking at themselves in mirrors, and cats trying to fight their own reflections. Adorable though this scenario may be, some psychologists see it as something deeper, a test of self-awareness.

Charles Darwin was once struck by an orangutan named Jenny gazing into a mirror and wondered whether she recognized herself. Over a century later, psychologist Gordon G. Gallup designed an experiment to test this, marking the faces of chimpanzees with a small amount of dye and observing their reactions when placing a full-length mirror before them.1 Although the experiment’s methodology and assumed implications have been criticized on a number of different fronts, this Mirror Self-Recognition (MSR) test has since been adapted to study a variety of different animals over the years. Orangutans, chimpanzees, dolphins, orcas, magpies, and ghost crabs have supposedly passed versions of the test; dogs, cats, giant pandas, baboons, and cichlids have supposedly not.

Failing the test has been taken to imply a lack of self-awareness, which could in turn have significant evolutionary and cross-species implications. As Jennie Coy explains, in order to cooperate like a human is (at least theoretically) able to, ‘an animal has to be sufficiently aware of itself: first, to place itself in relation to the environment; secondly, to perceive itself as having an effect on that environment; and, thirdly, to be aware of the other individual as separate from itself.’2 Self-awareness has controversially been even further connected to questions of intelligence and rationality, traits that have in the past been considered unique to humans and thus separating them from non-human animals. As recently as 1988, Tim Ingold noted, ‘The view that non-human animals may be regarded as self-conscious subjects with thoughts and feelings of their own is still something of a heresy in ethological and psychological circles.’3

Darwin’s observations and the MSR test came well after the Middle Ages, but there are a few medieval tales reflecting the underlying premise that certain animals are unable to recognize their own reflections. The first is a fable commonly titled ‘The Dog and Its Reflection’. Aesop’s version of the fable describes how a dog carrying a piece of meat sees its reflection in a body of water. Thinking that it is looking at a different dog with another piece of food, it opens its mouth to attack. In doing so, it drops its own food in the water, leaving it with nothing.

Aberdeen University Library, Univ. Lib. MS 24, fol. 19r.

This was an extremely popular fable, with versions of it adapted across the world and throughout the Middle Ages. The c. 1200 Aberdeen Bestiary, for instance, describes the dog losing meat upon seeing its shadow as a somewhat convoluted allegory for preachers ‘driving off the ambushes laid by the Devil’. In most renditions, the fable is used as a more straightforward moral message against greed; in some others like in the thirteenth-century Icelandic Hemings þáttr, the message is more political.4 Whatever the subtext may be, every version of the fable is based on the assumption that a dog would not be able to recognize its own reflection.

A second similarly confused animal is the tiger. Medieval animal texts like the Aberdeen Bestiary describe a somewhat cruel ploy to capture a tiger cub and escape the wrath of its mother: ‘When [the thief] sees the tigress drawing close, he throws down a glass sphere. The tigress is deceived by her own image in the glass and thinks it is her stolen cub. She abandons the chase, eager to gather up her young. […] And thus, trapped by the intensity of her sense of duty, she loses both her revenge and her child.’

Aberdeen University Library, Univ. Lib. MS 24, fol. 8r.

This case is slightly more complex. Like the fable dog, the tigress is unable to recognize its own reflection, but does at least evidently understand the reflection to be a familial member of its own species. Of course, the small size of the glass sphere contributes to this confusion, as does the ‘intensity of her sense of duty’ as a mother.

There is an unstated but strong assumption across both stories that a human being would be able to correctly parse their reflection and not succumb to the same errors as the other animals. Reflection stories about humans or half-humans from Narcissus to mermaids are usually concerned with the dangers of pride, vanity, and luxury, but this is all the price of human intelligence. As Joyce Salisbury explains, to medieval philosophers, ‘the main principle defining animals was their perceived lack of intellect, “reason.”’5 The dog and tiger bestiary stories suggest that self-awareness was also tied to human intellect and reason at this time, and, in fact, centuries before Darwin and Gallup, a medieval Mirror Self-Recognition test was already being theorized.

Ashley Castelino, DPhil
Public Humanities Postdoctoral Fellow
Medieval Institute, University of Notre Dame

  1. Gordon G. Gallup, Jr., ‘Chimpanzees: Self-Recognition’, Science, 167.3914 (1970), pp. 86–87. ↩︎
  2. Jennie Coy, ‘Animals’ Attitudes to People’, in What is an Animal?, ed. by Tim Ingold (Routledge, 1988), pp. 77–83 (p. 80). ↩︎
  3. Introduction to What is an Animal?, ed. by Tim Ingold (Routledge, 1988), pp. 1–16 (p. 6). ↩︎
  4. Hemings þáttr, in Icelandic Sagas and Other Historical Documents Relating to the Settlements and Descents of the Northmen of the British Isles, vol. I, Orkneyinga saga and Magnus saga, with Appendices, ed. by Guðbrandur Vigfússon (Cambridge University Press, 2012), pp. 347–87 (p. 366). ↩︎
  5. Joyce Salisbury, The Beast Within: Animals in the Middle Ages, 2nd edn (Routledge, 2011), p. 4. ↩︎

The Ambiguous Medieval Bat: Fables on Treachery and Survival

In the Middle Ages, the bat was understood to occupy an unusual position amongst animals. Ancient and medieval authors were well aware that while bats have wings and fly, like birds do, they also have teeth, give birth to live young, and produce milk—none of which are avian traits. Premodern taxonomies (systems of classification for living things) differed significantly from modern ones;1 the bat in the medieval period was often spoken of as a bird with some “quadruped” characteristics.2 For example, some twelfth-century bestiaries, drawing directly from Ambrose’s Hexameron (Book 5, 24.87), say:

The bat [vespertilio], an ignoble animal, takes its name from “evening” [vespere]. Moreover, it is both flying and a quadruped, and uses its teeth, which you may not be accustomed to finding in other birds. It gives birth like quadrupeds, not as eggs, but as living young.3

Illustration of a bat from the early 13th c. Ashmole Bestiary (Bodleian Library, MS. Ashmole 1511), fol. 63r.

The bat’s liminal nature was fodder for medieval fables as well. The most popular medieval bat fable (or at least, the one extant in the greatest number of versions)4 was The Bat and the Birds (Perry Index 566). In this fable, a bat attempts to play both sides in a conflict between quadrupeds and birds, and is ultimately punished for his duplicity.

Ambiguity as Deceptive

A Latin verse version by medieval English author Alexander Neckam, who lived in the late twelfth to early thirteenth century, goes as follows:

De vespertilione et avibus
Quadrupedes et aves gererent dum bella furentes
et modo quadrupedes, nunc fugerent volucres,
versutus vespertilio se iunxit utrisque
ut, quicquid fieret, tutus untrinque foret.
Auribus et mammis se quadrupedem simulabat,
credi par alis alitibus poterat.
Hac se fraude tegens inter fera prelia tutus
fallebat stolidum cautus utrumque genus.
Ut fraus nota fuit, genus hunc abiecit utrumque
et merito placuit ut neutrum neutri.
Hac re quadrupedes et aves dum vespere pausant,
antique fraudis conscius ipse fugit.
Sic qui se fallax nunc his nunc ingerit illis,
omnibus ingratus, iure repulsus erit.5

My translation:

The Bat and the Birds
While the quadrupeds and birds were waging a furious war, and at times the quadrupeds were fleeing, at other times the birds, the cunning bat united himself to both, so that, whatever happened, he would be safe from both sides. He resembled the quadrupeds in his ears and teats, and could be taken for a bird because of his wings. So, deceptively hiding himself, safe amongst the fighting beasts, the cautious one tricked the foolish ones of both kinds. When the deceit was known, both kinds cast him out, and he deservedly was accepted by neither one nor the other. Because of this, when quadrupeds and birds rest in the evening, he, conscious of the earlier deception, flees. Thus, whichever deceitful one pushes himself onto first some, then onto others, will justly be rejected, unacceptable to all.

The bat in the fable of The Bat and the Birds values self-protection above “loyalty” to one party or another, and sits uneasily between categories. Neckam’s version construes his strategy as clever, but deceptive, and judges his ultimate status as an exile as well-deserved, and perhaps inevitable.

Illustration of the War of the Birds and the Beasts, in an 1863 edition of Croxall’s Fables of Aesop, p. 228.

While Neckam’s moral is pretty general, moralizing the conflicting groups as “some” and “others” whom one shouldn’t act fickle towards, other medieval (and modern) moralists were more direct in casting the fable in political terms. William Caxton’s Aesop (1484) proclaims:

And therfore he that wylle serue two lordes contrary one to other may not be good ne trewe/ And they whiche relynquen and leue theyr owne lordes for to seruve another straunger/ whiche is enemy to theyr lord/ ben wel worthy to be punysshed/6

(And therefore, he that will serve two lords opposed to one another cannot be good or faithful. And those who abandon and leave their own lords to serve another foreigner who is enemy to their lord are well worthy to be punished.)

Eighteenth-century churchman Samuel Croxall, meanwhile, waxed fervent about deserters and traitors to one’s country:

For any one to desert the interest of his country, and turn renegado, either out of fear, or any prospect of advantage, is so notoriously vile and low, that it is no wonder if the man, who is determined in it, is for ever ashamed to see the sun, and to show himself in the eyes of those whose cause he has betrayed.7

Illustration of a bat from a bestiary, British Library, Harley MS 3244, folio 55v.

The bat’s ambiguous nature does not jibe well with Caxton’s and Croxall’s denouncements, which compare him to someone who deserts their lord or betrays their country. Indeed, perhaps his nature, as the fables have it, does not jibe well with the genre’s broader tendency to naturalize and essentialize social categories, by using animals as metaphors for humans, as I have discussed in previous posts. Fables map species differences to human social differences, and in so doing, often portray these social differences as inherent and immutable—stark as the differences between a donkey and a lion, or a wolf and a sheep.

But, after all, which group should the bat try to belong to, in this fable? If he were to side only with the quadrupeds, the birds might deem him a traitor, and vice versa. His characteristics align him with both sides. In a sense, by allying with both sides at different points in time, he is being true to his own nature, which is ambiguous. This ambiguity can render him safer, but it can also render him more vulnerable.

Ambiguity as Adaptive

Another bat fable depicts the bat’s ambiguous characteristics as potentially adaptive in the face of danger, and indeed as something for humans to emulate. In the fable of The Bat and the Weasel (Perry Index 172), a bat is captured by a weasel and pleads for his life. The weasel insists that she cannot spare the bat, since she is the enemy of all winged creatures. Declaring that he is not a bird, but a mouse, the bat is freed.8 Then, he is caught by a second weasel, who claims to hate all mice. The bat now insists he is not a mouse, but a bat, and he is once again released. The conclusion: “The fable demonstrates that we too must not persist in the same devices, reckoning that those who adapt themselves to circumstances often escape dangers.”9

Image of a bat from Bibliothèque d’Amiens Métropole, MS. 399 folio 149r.

Together, these bat fables speak not only to the perceived ambiguity of the bat as a creature, but the perceived ambiguity of being ambiguous. Those who don’t fit into a single category can face mistrust and disapprobation, but that same liminality can also be a source of strength.

Linnet Heald
PhD in Medieval Studies
University of Notre Dame

  1. See Susan Crane, “A Taxonomy of Creatures in the Second-Family Bestiary,” in New Medieval Literatures vol. 10, issue 1 (2008), pp. 1-48, for an insightful analysis of medieval bestiary taxonomy, for instance. ↩︎
  2. Live birth and the production of milk are of course mammal traits, not quadruped traits per se. The taxonomic category of “mammals” was introduced by Carl Linnaeus in the eighteenth century, however, and would be anachronistic here. Interestingly, Linnaeus categorized both bats and humans as primates. ↩︎
  3. Vespertilio, animal ignobile, a vespere nomen accepit. Est autem volatile idemque quadrupes, et dentibus utitur, quos in aliis avibus reperire non soleas. Parit ut quadrupedia, non ova sed pullos viventes. Latin text from Willene B. Clark, A Medieval Book of Beasts: The Second-Family Bestiary (The Boydell Press, 2006), p. 182. Translations in this post are mine (unless otherwise stated). My own translation above differs little from Clark’s, but Clark notably translates ut quadrupedia as “like mammals.” ↩︎
  4. See Francisco Rodríguez Adrados, History of the Graeco-Latin Fable, vol.3 (Brill, 2003), p. 727. ↩︎
  5. Giovanni Garbugino, ed., Alessandro Neckam, Novus Aesopus, Favolisti latini medievali, vol. 2. (Università di Genova Facoltà di Lettere, 1987), p. 56. ↩︎
  6. R. T. Lenaghan, ed., Caxton’s Aesop, Edited with an Introduction and Notes (Harvard University Press, 1967), p. 107. ↩︎
  7. Samuel Croxall, Fables of Aesop and Others, Translated into English, with Instructive Applications, and One Hundred and Ninety-Eight Illustrations (Boston: T. O. H. P. Burnham, 1863), p. 229. ↩︎
  8. There is some slippage in terminology here—the bat didn’t deny he was winged, he denied he was a bird! However, this assertion satisfies the first captor. ↩︎
  9. I have epitomized L. Radif’s Italian translation, from Greek, of the fable’s narrative; the moral is, as Radif renders it, “La favola mostra che bisogna che anche noi non persistiamo negli stessi accorgimenti, calcolando che coloro che si adeguano alle circostanze spesso sfuggono ai pericoli.” L. Radif, “Il vespertilio protagonista di una favola di Alessandro Neckam,” Favolisti latini medievali e umanistici, vol. 7 (Università di Genova Facoltà di Lettere, 1998), p. 79. ↩︎